A new public consultation on the Barroso lithium mine opened today, November 13, with residents’ association Unidos em Defesa de Covas do Barroso (UDCB) rejecting the procedure, accusing environmental authorities of trying to repair an approval that should never have been issued.
Anti-mining groups are encouraging people to examine the proposals and submit objections before the December 4 deadline, as the long-running battle over the project enters another stage.
The consultation concerns the mine’s RECAPE — the report intended to demonstrate that its detailed design complies with the conditions attached to the environmental approval granted in May 2023.
For UDCB, however, the fundamental question remains unresolved: whether the project’s environmental risks were adequately assessed before that approval was given.
The association argues that the Portuguese Environment Agency (APA) deferred essential studies on water resources, air quality, noise, waste and biodiversity until later stages, adopting what it describes as an “approve first, assess later” approach.
A procedure designed to check compliance with existing conditions cannot retrospectively remedy those shortcomings, it maintains.
“This RECAPE is dead on arrival,” UDCB president Nélson Gomes blasts in a statement today.
“Trying to use a compliance procedure to whitewash an Environmental Impact Declaration with scientific shortcomings, which has been challenged by the Public Prosecutor’s Office, is an insult to the population of Covas do Barroso,” he said.
Gomes accuses APA of attempting to carry out the environmental impact assessment after the event – leaving communities and the courts to deal with the risks.
Warnings over dust, water and mining waste
In its statement, UDCB cites independent assessments which it says exposed serious weaknesses in the project’s environmental studies.
An assessment by air-quality specialist Dr Douw G. Steyn, dated November 2025, criticised reliance on just 14 days of measurements of PM10 particles, according to the association. It also identified shortcomings in modelling air pollution across the local terrain and the absence of a plan to manage dust escaping from mining operations.
UDCB also points to an April 2023 assessment by geophysics and hydrology specialist Dr Steven H. Emerman, raising concerns about the proposed mine-waste storage facility.
According to the association’s account of his findings, the facility would reach 140 metres in height and present risks associated with steep slopes, liquefaction, with any possible failure affecting the River Covas.
The association accuses APA of disregarding both experts’ warnings.
Court challenges and access to land
UDCB says the May 2023 environmental decision is being challenged in the Administrative and Tax Court of Mirandela, where, according to the association, the Public Prosecutor’s Office has supported its annulment over deficiencies in the assessment of waste and water-related risks.
The association also cites findings by the United Nations Aarhus Convention Compliance Committee concerning Portugal’s failure to uphold rights of access to information and public participation in the process. A consultation at this later stage cannot undo those breaches, it argues.
Alongside its environmental objections, UDCB denounces the use of administrative powers to secure access to private and common land despite opposition from owners and local communities.
Its statement refers to government measures adopted in December 2024 and June 2026 which it says allowed work to proceed while legal challenges remained pending.
The association also opposes the mine’s designation as a European Strategic Project, saying that status is being used to accelerate administrative procedures. It says the designation is being challenged before the EU’s General Court.
What is proposed
The company intends to extend the mine’s operating period to 15 years, expand the waste rock deposits by 13,4% and almost double the area designated for water management.
The mine’s impact on water in the affected area has been one of the arguments used by local communities against lithium mining in Covas do Barroso. According to Público, a new study concluded that pumping water from the open pits – the open-air excavations from which the ore is extracted – will cause the water level of nearby springs to drop by between 44 and 52 centimeters, which would only recover seven and a half years after mining ends – a period that increases to between 18 and 27 years in the case of the open pits.
The report also adds that the map of groundwater levels was made using data collected at a time of year when there was plenty of water, failing to show what could happen during a drought. And it acknowledges that water passing through the waste deposits, after the open pits are filled, could flow towards the Covas River (causing the contamination that locals have always predicted and feared).
According to messages circulated over social media by anti-mining groups today, the project involves a concession covering around 593 hectares, with approximately 73.1 hectares devoted directly to mining, an industrial ore-processing plant, new access roads and supporting infrastructure.
The concession area and the direct mining area are different measures; the smaller figure should not be read as the project’s total footprint.
The posts identify affected areas in Boticas — Covas do Barroso, Dornelas and Vilar e Viveiro — and Canedo, in neighbouring Ribeira de Pena.
Campaigners are urging members of the public to read the documents and submit formal comments by December 4, arguing that the consultation offers another opportunity to challenge the project’s consequences for the territory and its communities.
Considering this latest consultation exercise only opened today, it already has a significant number of ‘participations’ (over 2,000 and climbing), and has seen a passionate opinion article published in the local diariotrasosmontes online, which particularly highlights the effects on water courses.
Can it all be worth it, is the question – which returns neatly to the warning by Portuguese water specialist and former PSD environmental secretary, Joaquim Poças Martins, years atrás: “You cannot destroy a mountain in order to extract a handful of lithium” (by handful, he was referring to the fact that these lithium deposits are finite).
Source material: statement from UDCB/ Diariotrasosmontes.com/ Público
