Banks operating in Portugal are required to immediately reimburse customers who are victims of scams – even when they believe that the customer themselves was grossly careless with their data.
The rule stems from a ruling by the Court of Justice of the European Union and, according to the Bank of Portugal, was already in force in the country.
The Luxembourg court ruled, on October 15, that a customer’s alleged gross negligence does not exempt the bank from its duty to immediately restore the amount of an unauthorised payment transaction. Only after returning the money can the institution try to recover it – and it is up to the institution, not the customer, to prove that there was gross negligence or deliberate non-compliance with security rules. If the customer refuses to pay, the bank will have to take the matter to court.
The decision relates to a case in Poland. A woman selling a product online received a message from a fake buyer with a link that imitated her bank’s website. After entering her details, money was taken from her account. The bank, PKO BP, refused reimbursement on the grounds that the customer had been negligent, and a Polish court asked the Court of Justice of the EU to interpret the European payment services directive. The response came back in favour of the defrauded customer. The judges ruled that allowing the bank to refuse reimbursement from the outset would render the obligation of immediate reimbursement meaningless, and force the victim to go to court herself.
Explaining all this today, Correio da Manhã stresses that the decision applies only to situations in which the scammer manages to access the account and carry out the transactions him/ herself. Cases in which the customer actually gives the payment order – even if deceived by third parties – are excluded from the ruling (in other words, the money handed over does not have to be reimbursed by the bank).
The Bank of Portugal maintains that national law already follows this interpretation of the European Payment Services Directive and that, when supervising payment service providers, it has required immediate reimbursement of unauthorised transactions, resorting to supervisory measures and administrative offence proceedings when this does not happen. There was, however, some room for different interpretations, which this new ruling now puts to rest, adds CM.
State bank Caixa Geral de Depósitos has also assured that it is already following this procedure and that the European court’s decision does not change the way it handles such cases.
Source: Correio da Manhã
